bentleystrategy.com

The Story CMOs Need to Tell About AI and Marketing Technology

CMOs are exceptional storytellers, but few have turned those skills on the internal audience that controls their AI and martech budget. The story you tell your CEO, CFO, and CTO is the real unlock, with a five-step playbook for getting to alignment in one week.

Your CEO wants to know your AI strategy. Your vendors are pitching the next generation of everything. Your IT team has a backlog that stretches to next year. And somewhere in the middle of all of that, your data and technology foundation is still a work in progress, making it hard to know where to start.

Here's what I've learned after navigating these transformations: the CMOs who break through aren't always the most technical. They're the best storytellers. And the most important story you can tell right now isn't for your customers. It's for your CEO, your CFO, and your CTO.

In this article

• Why your marketing growth story depends on data and technology capabilities your company may not have built yet.
• How to turn a capability gap into a business case your CEO and CFO will fund, and your CTO will execute.
• A five-step playbook for getting aligned and moving in one week.

Why the CMO must own the narrative

CMOs are, by training and instinct, exceptional storytellers. They know how to connect with audiences emotionally, make abstract ideas succinct and concrete, and move people to take action. Those are exactly the skills required to make progress on customer data, technology, and AI initiatives. Most CMOs just haven't brought those same storytelling skills to the data and technology problems that are limiting growth.

What I've seen instead are two common patterns. The first: the CMO tries to solve the technology problem directly, gets deep into vendor evaluations without the technical background to assess them, and ends up with a solution IT doesn't support and won't maintain. The second: the CMO hands the problem to IT, gets told it's in the queue, and spends the next two years waiting.

Neither typically works, and both share the same root cause: the story was never told and embraced across the organization.

In most organizations I've worked in, marketing technology decisions have been made in IT, funded by Finance, and executed by vendors, with the CMO somewhere in the middle, trying to influence without owning. That has to change. If you are being asked to drive growth through transformation, and most of you are, the reins on customer data, technology, and AI strategy need to be in your hands. I'll address the full organizational implications of that in later articles. But regardless of how your company is structured, you need a compelling story.

The story is the unlock

Most capability gap conversations inside companies sound like this: "We need a better email platform" or "Our data isn't clean enough to do personalization." Those statements are accurate. But they don't move anyone to act. IT has heard versions of that complaint for years. Finance doesn't know what to do with it. The CEO moves on to the next agenda item.

The story that works always starts with the customer.

Here's an example: your customers want personalized product recommendations in their promotional emails, based on their interests, their profile, and their purchase history. Not based on what you're trying to push. You probably have most of that data somewhere in your systems. But you don't have a way to get it into your email platform, and you don't have the capability to build enough creative versions to make personalization viable at scale.

That's a data and Gen-AI technology problem. But here's how to tell it as a story that will get the organization to do something: if you build this capability, you estimate email conversion will improve by 5%. At your volume, that's $5 million in incremental annualized revenue and $1 million in incremental profit. Not just in year one. Every year after you make the investment. The engineering cost to solve it is approximately $500,000. That's a 2× return after year one and 6× after year three.

Now you have something Finance can model, IT can see the urgency behind, and your CEO can explain to the board.

That is the story you need to tell. And you are the only person who can tell it, because it requires connecting the customer experience to the data and technology gap to the financial outcome. IT doesn't have time to do it. The last thing they need is another C-level prioritized project. Finance can't do it, because they cannot make the connection between marketing capabilities, improved customer experience, and financial outcomes. And only Marketing can own the outcomes that will be delivered. This story must come from you.

The AI urgency makes this more complicated

At the same moment you're trying to close foundational data and technology gaps, AI is reshaping every platform you use. Your CEO is asking about your AI strategy. Vendors are pitching AI solutions on top of infrastructure you haven't finished building yet.

Most companies respond in one of two ways: they wait for the market to settle before making significant investments, or they sprint toward AI without fixing the foundation first. Both approaches will leave you further behind.

While I normally recommend ruthless prioritization and focus, in this case my recommendation is to do both at the same time. Fix foundational gaps aggressively while simultaneously piloting AI capabilities. The failures you encounter in your AI pilots will illuminate the foundational issues that matter most. That is useful. Let your AI ambitions surface the foundational gaps that need to be solved, and make sure every foundational project you fund is framed as an AI-readiness project. That framing alone will help you get it prioritized.

To be clear, you still can't do everything. You should also identify what you will not fix. For example, if you are implementing AI decisioning on top of your marketing platform and there are data gaps, focus only on the data gaps necessary to get a pilot out the door. Getting all of your internal data to be AI-ready is too large a project and will prevent you from moving quickly on AI implementation.

Fixing the foundation and moving fast on AI implementation at the same time is uncomfortable and will face resistance, not just from your own team but from your IT partners. It requires real investment, prioritization, and significant trade-offs. Which brings me to the playbook.

The Five-One Playbook (five steps, one week)

You don't need a six-month strategy and planning process to get started. Here's a framework for crafting a compelling story and getting real commitment in one week.

1. Personify the capability gap through the customer lens. Don't start with technology. Start with the customer experience that the technology will enable. What are your customers unable to get from you today that they want, and may be getting from competitors? Make it specific and make it human. The more visceral the customer story, the more it will resonate across the C-suite. If you find yourself starting with an architectural diagram, you've probably already lost your audience.
2. Find the root causes. Work backwards from the customer experience gap to understand why it exists. It's almost never one cause. It's very likely a combination of missing data, integration gaps, technology limitations, and skills. But sometimes, and more often than you'd expect, the problem exists simply because IT was never told it was a business priority. I've seen significant issues get resolved quickly once a CMO clearly articulated the customer problem being left unsolved, what the ideal end state looked like, and what it was worth to the business to get there. IT can't prioritize what they don't fully understand. Don't assume the obstacle is technical until you've had that conversation.
3. Quantify the impact. Translate the customer experience gap into financial terms. What revenue or profit improvement is possible if you solve it? Build a multi-year view, not just year one. These are not one-time capital investments with a single payoff. They are recurring investments that compound over time through improved customer growth and retention metrics. Finance needs to understand that distinction, and it is your job to make it clear. Bring a Finance partner in early. Ask to borrow an analyst to help build the business case in their language.
4. Build the funding path. Be prepared to make tough choices. If you genuinely believe these capabilities will drive meaningful growth, you should be willing to redirect dollars from activities with lower long-term returns, including paid media or brand spending, to fund the investment. One thing worth knowing: your CFO may be more receptive to technology investments that can be classified as capital expenditures rather than operating expenses. Moving Marketing OpEx dollars into IT CapEx development projects has real accounting advantages, and it signals to your CEO that you are thinking about the enterprise, not just your department.
5. Get a formal commitment, not just agreement. A compelling story that doesn't result in a concrete next step is just a good presentation. Before you leave the room, you need IT to commit to putting this on their next sprint schedule or development plan. You need Finance to confirm the funding path, whether that's a new budget allocation, CFO sign-off, or a reallocation from your own budget. Verbal alignment in a meeting is not a commitment. Establish what happens next, who owns it, and when it shows up on a plan. Also ensure there is a dedicated project manager on the project, and make sure you personally stay engaged to understand blockers and help remove them.

What the best CMOs have in common

CMOs who drive real marketing technology transformation share one trait: they build internal cross-functional coalitions around customer outcomes. They don't wait for IT to prioritize their requests. They don't let Finance misclassify their investments as discretionary spending. They tell a story that makes the business case impossible to ignore, and then they follow it all the way to a formal commitment.

You've spent your career learning how to tell stories that move customers. That skill has never been more valuable. The audience that needs to hear your best work is sitting right down the hall.